The In-Between

The Lovely Bones is the odd movie out from Peter Jackson’s post-Lord of the Rings work. It’s not a 3 hour epic, but special effects are a highlight. I was intrigued to see The Lovely Bones mostly for Jackson’s directing. Even though I knew the subject matter would leave me depressed. The ending was depressing, but everything else made me angry. Since a young person taken from this world too soon is a terrible tragedy that no one should ever endure. The 14 year old Susie Salmon is much too innocent for this evil world. All she wants is to become a photographer and kiss the boy of her dreams.

Her heartbreaking death in 1973 is at the hands of the despicable Harvey when he lures Susie into a den under a corn field. The 2002 novel sounds so much more horrific, but it’s the supernatural element that was probably hardest to translate. Susie doesn’t become a ghost. Instead she ends up in the In-Between. A brightly colorful and even psychedelic personal Heaven with an upbeat tone. The cast is full of major celebrities like Mark Wahlberg as the father, Rachel Weisz as the mother, and Susan Sarandon as the grandmother. A young Saoirse Ronan delivers a breakout performance as Susie and Stanley Tucci was so convincingly evil as Harvey that he was nominated for Best Supporting Actor.

My praise kind of stops there, because the disjointed tonal shifts didn’t work for me. The comedic grandmother feels especially out of place. I’d say it would’ve worked better without the In-Between, but that would’ve made it more depressing. The grief the Salmon family feels trying to search for Susie’s killer is particularly realistic on its own. The only direct supernatural aspect is an outsider from Susie’s school sensing her presence. The closure and brutal justice I was hoping Harvey would receive, ended up feeling disappointing. The Lovely Bones saves itself with a positive message wishing us all to have a long and happy life.

The Lovely Bones

Susie Salmon

8 thoughts on “The In-Between

  1. This reminds me that I still haven’t seen this one! I haven’t read the novel, but a friend had said it was quite brilliant if somewhat grim. I think maybe that’s maybe what put me off the movie at the time.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I absolutely agree. It had the potential to be so much better but, like you say, it was too disjointed. My oldest daughter loved the book. Stanley Tucci is a brilliant actor and he has never been better than he is here. I liked the way he got his comeuppance–it’s very realistic, if you read about cold case files and the perpetrators of such crimes. It is unsatisfactory unless you believe, as I do, that real justice begins in the afterlife.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. HATED it! In my opinion, the movie is a huge mess. Love Saoirse, but Tucci was a walking stereotype. BTW, my wife read the book and told me that the movie didn’t do justice to a great book.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s