Sometimes, Dead is Better

Pet Sematary is the final Stephen King adaptation released in the 80’s. It was buried for so long since King has called it the scariest book he’s ever written. Although the themes are creepy and saddening, the movie can only go so far. The misspelled Pet Sematary centers on a pet cemetery that mysteriously brings animals back to life. It’s a personal story that King based on similar life experiences. So much so that King wrote the movie himself. Pet Sematary follows the Creed family as they move to a traditional Maine town. The only thing off about their new home are trucks that speed down the street and the titular cemetery down the road.

Dale Midkiff doesn’t stand out as Dr. Louis Creed, but Fred Gwynne is a major presence as their heavily accented neighbor Jud Crandall. Denise Crosby plays Louis’ wife Rachel a year after quitting The Next Generation. Their children are the ambiguously supernatural Ellie and adorable toddler Gage. There’s the usual uncomfortable talk about religion, but their cat Church is actually named after Winston Churchill. When Church dies, Jud tells Louis how to bring him back to life. A soft grey cat can only look so intimidating, but Church coming back wrong is unsettling. “Sometimes, dead is better.”

Other creepy happenings are an undead patient named Victor Pascow warning characters not to use the cemetery and Rachel remembering her sister Zelda who died of a spinal disease. Neither compare to Gage being tragically struck by an oncoming truck. It’s part of the reason why I avoided watching the movie, but it is offscreen. What isn’t offscreen is Louis bringing Gage back to life as a murderous child. 3 year old Miko Hughes is still cute, but surprisingly terrifying. SPOILER ALERT! Jud dies an unexpectedly graphic death and Rachel returns only to die as well. A detatched Louis puts down his cat and son before bringing his wife back. Pet Sematary isn’t the instant Stephen King classic I thought it would be, but it’s lively enough.

Pet Sematary

Church hisses

Followed by: Pet Sematary Two

6 thoughts on “Sometimes, Dead is Better

  1. Of Stephen King’s novels that I’ve read so far, Pet Sematary is by far the scariest in my opinion. I found things to like about both film adaptations, but when it comes to the scares, they don’t touch the book. I had to quit reading about halfway through because it was affecting my dreams and that doesn’t typically happen to me. I think I took about a month long break before coming back and finishing the book. Absolutely terrifying.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Pet Sematary is definitely the scariest of all of Stephen King’s books.

    And I found Pet Sematary to be the scariest Stephen King movie as well.

    The returned to life toddler was terrifying.

    It’s also very interesting that Pet Sematary turned out to be your 1666th review. πŸ™€

    This is also the first I heard that the plot of the book was a personal story of King’s based on real life experiences. 😱

    Did King once bury a pet or someone who came back from the dead?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. All I know is that Stephen King once had a cat who was killed by a similar oncoming truck. He explained death to his daughter and later wondered what would happen if the cat or a child came back fundamentally wrong.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s