Maleficent ruined the greatest Disney villain in one fell swoop. Sleeping Beauty has been one of my personal favorite Disney animated films since childhood. Although I was open to the live-action Disney remake of Alice in Wonderland (2010), I was against Maleficent from the start. Most people know that Sleeping Beauty spends more time with its supporting characters than its titular princess. I’ll admit it made some sense to dedicate an entire movie to the more well defined villain, but not at the expense of her wickedness. It’s no surprise that Disney was inspired by the success of the Broadway play Wicked.
Maleficent was nearly an animated movie in the early 2000’s directed by Tim Burton. Other projects including Alice in Wonderland (2010) forced several delays. By the time Disney acquired Pixar, Maleficent became the latest live-action Disney reimagining. Despite attracting several prominent directors, the job ultimately went to production designer Robert Stromberg. By the time my brother and I saw Maleficent in theaters, we were equally frustrated with the sympathetic reevaluation of the classic fairy tale. Maleficent may miss the mark, but casting Angelina Jolie is about the only good thing to come out of it…
Maleficent is technically the first live-action Disney Princess movie. Even though it’s from the perspective of the villain. Angelina Jolie was always the only choice to play Maleficent. She brought the Disney villain to life the same way Glen Close did for Cruella de Vil. It proved to be a major comeback for Jolie and the highest grossing film of her career. Though I don’t agree with its financial success, Maleficent did deserve an Oscar nomination for Best Costume Design. Maleficent has the long black horns, sharp cheek bones, and elegant black robes of her animated counterpart. Except her skin isn’t pale green. Although Maleficent’s name literally means βto cause harm,β she’s given a sympathetic backstory that makes it difficult to see her as the self-proclaimed “Mistress of All Evil.”
In the original fairy tale, the villain is the Wicked fairy. So the movie leans into her being a fairy by giving her wings. Isobelle Molloy and Ella Purnell play the young Maleficent with horns, pointy ears, long hair, and brown wings. Once upon a time, Maleficent lived in a magical forest called the Moors. Since Stromberg worked on Avatar, the Moors are basically a less inspired Pandora populated by ugly CGI creatures. Giant living trees serve as guards and alert Maleficent to a human thief. At first it seems like King Stefan will be Maleficent’s true love. The young Stefan is an orphan just like Maleficent. Apparently the opening was reshot several times and at one point included Maleficent’s aunt and uncle played by Miranda Richardson and Peter Capaldi. When they were removed, the focus was placed on her childhood romance.
Stefan specifically discovers fairies can be harmed by iron. Despite caring for Maleficent, Stefan seeks power from the human kingdom. Kenneth Cranham is the ruthless King Henry who wages war against the Moors. A grown up Maleficent swoops in and commands her army of trees to overwhelm them. On his death bed, the king promises his crown to the one who kills the fairy. The unlikable Sharlto Copley plays the older Stefan with a thick Scottish accent. Though he comes to warn Maleficent, he crosses the line by drugging her and chopping off her wings. For a PG rated Disney movie, the scene is very much a metaphor for rape. As much as I don’t want to sympathize with Maleficent, Jolie’s pained screams are uncomfortably convincing.
Maleficent fashions her staff out of a stick and rescues a crow to serve as her wings. Her pet bird Diablo is also ruined by Maleficent transforming him into a human servant named Diaval. Diaval emotes more than enough times as a crow, so having her talk to Sam Riley is a pointless change. When Maleficent learns why her wings were taken, she becomes the dark ruler of the Moors. The plot of Sleeping Beauty officially kicks in when they learn about the christening of the newborn Princess Aurora. I can almost look past the treatment of Maleficent, but I absolutely hate what Disney did to the three good fairies. Flora, Fauna, and Merryweather are now three selfish pixies named Knotgrass, Flittle, and Thistlewit. Not only are those terrible names, each actress has their face poorly rendered onto an uncanny CGI body.
After her brief CGI role in Alice in Wonderland (2010), Imelda Staunton plays the controlling Knotgrass modeled after Flora. Lesley Manville plays the prideful Flittle modeled after Merryweather. Juno Temple plays the airheaded Thistlewit modeled after Fauna. Although the three fairies know Maleficent from the Moors, they’re still invited by the closed off King Stefan. Not only is Queen Leah now named Queen Leila, Hannah New only appears in one scene. Arguably the one good scene in the entire movie. The christening scene is a perfect almost word for word recreation of the original opening. It’s the most evil Maleficent is allowed to be and even includes an evil laugh. Though Maleficent is more angry at Stefan than mad about not being invited. She uses her green magic to place a sleeping curse on Aurora, but Maleficent herself adds true love’s kiss only after Stefan begs.
Maleficent now uses her thorny wall to keep out the kingdom. Stefan has every spinning wheel in the kingdom destroyed like the original, but letting the fairies raise Aurora was a bad decision. The three pixies are an annoying trio of idiots who treat baby Aurora like an inconvenience, neglect her, and have no idea how to take care of her. They never even bother to call her Briar Rose. Only by ruining the three good fairies, are they able to turn Maleficent into a caring guardian. The only evil she does is casually messing with the pixies. For some reason, Maleficent and Diaval awkwardly watch Aurora grow up and do a much better job raising her. Jolie’s own 5 year old daughter plays the young Aurora when every other child actress was too afraid of her. Although Aurora is the third Disney Princess, the blonde and beautiful Elle Fanning is the first actress to play a live-action Disney Princess. Maleficent and Aurora officially meet when the former puts her to sleep and leads her into the Moors.
Aurora is so innocent and naive that she thinks Maleficent is her fairy godmother. They spend way too much time together and Maleficent starts to care for her “Beastie.” It gets to a point where she actually tries to lift the curse, but fails without true love’s kiss. Prince Phillip is just as neutral as Aurora. Brenton Thwaites has nothing to do aside from being the handsome prince. Phillip and Aurora awkwardly meet in the forest without a romantic duet. Aurora wants to live with Maleficent, but her aunts tell her the truth and she runs to the kingdom by herself. The queen casually dies off-screen and Stefan barely cares about his daughter’s return. If Maleficent is basically the hero, King Stefan is turned into an overly psychotic villain. Maleficent is too late to keep Aurora from pricking her finger, but she does bring the unconscious prince. SPOILER ALERT! Unfortunately, Phillip doesn’t save the day or even break the curse. After Frozen, it became painfully obvious that the Mistress of Evil would break her own curse.
Maleficent is not a motherly figure, but that didn’t stop Once Upon a Time from using those changes in later seasons of the show. Stefan and his army manage to trap Maleficent in an iron net. The final insult was ruining an iconic climax by having Maleficent transform Diaval into a dragon instead of becoming one herself. Instead Aurora frees her magic wings and she uses them to drop Stefan to his death. Without a kingdom, Aurora rules over the Moors with the loving Maleficent by her side. The three pixies are allowed to stay and Phillip is only there to smile at Aurora as they live happily ever after. Janet McTeer is the narrator who ends up being an older Aurora who ruins the fairy tale by calling Maleficent a hero and villain. Since Sleeping Beauty was never defined as a musical, the only song during the credits is “Once Upon a Dream” sung by a melodic Lana Del Rey. I know it will never be the definitive Sleeping Beauty, but Maleficent is still an insult to such a classic story.
Live-Action Retelling of: Sleeping Beauty & Followed by: Maleficent: Mistress of Evil