Beauty and the Beast (2017) is the first full blown musical live-action Disney remake. Although The Jungle Book (2016) used only its best songs, it can’t really be labeled a musical. Beauty and the Beast (1991) is easily one of the greatest musicals of all time and a beloved part of my childhood. Although Disney originally considered adapting the 1994 Broadway musical, the French fairy tale nearly got the Snow White and the Huntsman treatment instead. Until Dreamgirls and Twilight Saga director Bill Condon insisted on making an old fashioned musical. It was the right decision since Beauty and the Beast (2017) became the highest grossing live-action Disney remake at the time.
I’ll admit the trailer made me nostalgic the moment I heard the classic Alan Menken score. Beauty and the Beast (2017) is the first live-action remake of a movie from the Disney Renaissance. Unlike previous remakes, Beauty and the Beast (2017) makes a lot less changes to the overall story. Yet the hour and a half animated classic was still somehow expanded to over 2 hours. Aside from fixing plot holes, the remake adds additional songs composed by Menken himself. Like Alice in Wonderland (2010) and The Jungle Book (2016), my mom joined my brother and I to see Beauty and the Beast (2017) in theaters. Although there’s no competing with the first animated Best Picture nominee, there’s plenty to admire about this live-action remake…
Belle dances with the Beast
Beauty and the Beast (2017) manages to be just as visually stunning as the original. It was nominated for 2 Oscars including Best Costume Design and Best Production Design. Though it makes use of powdered wigs and old fashioned French architecture, there’s still plenty of color. Once upon a time, there was a Prince that lived in a magnificent French castle. The remake fills time by showing the Beast’s origin rather than using stained glass. Unlike what we saw in Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas, the Prince is a selfish grown man who taxes the kingdom. The beggar woman arrives during a lavish ball and we see him laugh at the Rose she gives him. As she becomes the beautiful Enchantress, the Beast is cursed with the same clawed portrait. This time the curse has lasted for an indeterminate amount of time and we’re given a much needed explanation for why villagers have no memory of their Prince or his enormous castle.
After Aurora and Cinderella, Belle became the next Disney Princess given the live-action treatment. Not only was Emma Watson born in France, she’s already proven herself as a headstrong book worm. After finishing her tenure as Hermione Granger, Beauty and the Beast (2017) became Watson’s most financially successful film since the Harry Potter franchise. Though Watson is a beautiful brunette like Belle, she’s no Paige O’Hara when it comes to vocal range. Her singing voice had to be auto-tuned. She’s still the funny girl in a poor providential town, yet she doesn’t stand out like the original when so many other villagers wear blue. Belle finds her escape through books, but apparently that’s not enough to make her odd. For some reason, Belle is now the family inventor who creates a horse powered laundry barrel. She’s also shunned for teaching a girl how to read.
Since he’s no longer a kooky inventor, Belle’s papa Maurice is a more serious artist who fondly remembers his late wife. It didn’t feel necessary to include an explanation for Belle’s late mother, but Kevin Kline gives a heartfelt performance. Maurice heads off with a music box and promises to bring back a rose just like the original fairy tale. Gaston is still a self-absorbed hunter determined to marry Belle, but now he’s a former member of the French Royal Army. Though he does have rugged good looks, Luke Evans is nowhere near as brawny as the animated Disney villain. His long red coat may be more accurate, but I can’t help but think of Captain Hook. Gaston attempts to woo Belle and propose marriage, but he’s not humiliated like the original. Belle simply rebuffs his advances. Beauty and the Beast (2017) has a bit more diversity than previous live-action Disney remakes. Though none of the main characters are race changed.
Most of the attention was given to Disney’s so-called “first gay character.” Olaf himself Josh Gad plays Gaston’s much more flamboyant sidekick LeFou. LeFou was certainly obsessed with Gaston before, but it was never a Mr. Burns and Smithers relationship. As a result, LeFou is a more sympathetic voice of reason who questions Gaston more often. When Maurice is lost in the woods with Philippe, he’s attacked by CGI wolves. He finds the enchanted castle like the original, but sadly he doesn’t make friends with any of the enchanted objects. Instead he’s frightened by Chip and immediately takes off, but not before plucking a white rose. Only then does he encounter the Beast. Belle rides back to the castle where she finds her father locked in the tower. The Beast reveals himself to have larger horns and a less animalistic design.
Although makeup would’ve worked just as well, motion capture was probably the better option. That way Dan Stevens’ facial performance can still shine through. Though the Beast retains his temper, something about his French mannerisms feels too soft. Except that he doesn’t offer Belle a room when she decides to replace her father. Instead she’s freed by the enchanted objects. As I expected, the enchanted objects are all done with photorealistic CGI. Animals are one thing, but you can’t put a cartoon face on a real life inanimate object. Lumière is a finely crafted candelabra that transforms into a man with a molded French coat and candle sitting atop his head. Although every character attempts a French accent, Ewan McGregor is the only one who needed to maintain the exaggerated accent of Jerry Orbach. Cogsworth is an intricate mantle clock with a similar arrow mustache. I wasn’t expecting the much older Sir Ian McKellen, but he does manage to be funny and dignified.
Lumière and Cogsworth show Belle to her room where we meet a radically different version of the Featherduster and Wardrobe. Lumière’s lover was named Fifi in Belle’s Magical World, but she’s now a swan-like feather duster named Plumette. Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Broadway singer Audra McDonald are the only black actresses who are both in interracial relationships. McDonald is the drowsy opera singing Madame de Garderobe. Her face can only be seen inside the wardrobe as a curtain. She’s separated from her husband Cadenza, an original harpsichord composer played by Stanley Tucci. Mrs. Potts is introduced a lot later than you’d expect. Though she’s still a motherly teapot, her face is now printed on the side. Emma Thompson is a perfectly respectable choice, but she’s no Angela Lansbury. The unknown Nathan Mack plays her teacup son Chip who looks and acts almost exactly the same. The footstool dog Sultan, coat rack, and stove chef are all accounted for.
The enchanted objects have to convince the Beast to invite Belle to dinner while she tries to escape through the window. After Belle is welcomed as a guest, she wanders the west wing where she finds the enchanted rose. I won’t harp on the delivery of every reused line, but so much of it feels off to me. Especially when the Beast orders Belle to get out in an overly rushed tone. Wolves attack her when she runs away and the Beast rescues her just like the original. The only necessary addition is a quick moment that explains how Belle managed to carry the injured Beast back to his castle. Meanwhile, a desperate Maurice returns to town where Gaston actually tries to help him find Belle. They search the woods, but Gaston goes from zero to attempted murder too quickly. Despite minor objection from LeFou, Gaston actually chains Maurice to a tree for the wolves to devour him. He’s saved by the local hag Agathe played by Hattie Morahan.
Back at the castle, Belle tends to the strangely muscular Beast in his bed. Though it doesn’t quite justify cursing the staff along with the Prince, Mrs. Potts tells Belle that they were cursed for allowing the King to turn him into the selfish ruler he became. Like Belle, the Beast also has a mother who passed away. Although I never saw it as Stockholm Syndrome, the remake tries to make their relationship more believable. Unfortunately, the Beast giving Belle his grand library is no longer a romantic gesture. Instead they form a bond by reading to each other and sharing similar feelings of being an outcast. The most unnecessary addition by far is the inclusion of a magical book that can take the Beast anywhere he wants to go. The enchanted mirror is already a window into the outside world, so it feels redundant.
The only purpose it serves is bringing Belle to her childhood home where her mother died from the Plague. It makes sense for the time period, but it’s a little dark for a PG rated Disney film. Belle and the Beast have fun in the snow and the iconic dance is not far behind. Though the dance doesn’t have the romantic build up, it does have Belle’s enchanting yellow dress and the Beast’s fancy blue suit. The ballroom may not be as enormous as the animated version, but their waltz is a highlight of the remake. When Maurice confronts Gaston, the latter makes him look insane and has him institutionalized. Belle sees her father with the enchanted mirror and the Beast barely gives a thought to letting her go. It’s a different approach that leaves no room for Chip as a stowaway. Belle confronts Gaston who convinces the mob that she’s under the Beast’s magic spell.
They ride off to kill the Beast and Belle is locked away with her father. Giving them time to talk about her mother. Without Chip, Belle and her father simply pick the lock. The final fight at the castle isn’t too different. Lumière, Cogsworth, and Mrs. Potts fight back in similar ways. Madame de Garderobe and Cadenza reunite as the former dresses a member of the mob who seems to like the makeover. Unlike the original, LeFou is redeemed when Gaston goes too far. He hunts the Beast in almost the same way. Except that Gaston shoots him in the back instead of stabbing him. Since the curse causes the castle to crumble, Gaston meets his death by falling from an unstable ledge. You’d think the Beast’s death in Belle’s arms would be just as emotional, but the enchanted objects becoming inanimate is a lot more tragic.
Agathe wanders inside the castle and is revealed to be the Enchantress. Belle professes her love and the Beast is revived as the handsome Prince that she kisses. It’s weird seeing every actor in person for the first time, but another welcomed change is giving the servants family members who lost their memory from the village. Mrs. Potts and Chip reunite with Mr. Potts and Cogsworth is reunited with his insufferable wife. Belle and the Prince enjoy one final ballroom dance as they live happily ever after. The seriously overblown “gay moment” that Bill Condon felt the need to announce months in advance, is just LeFou dancing with the wardrobe guy. It’s easily edited out and affects nothing, but the remake was still banned in several countries because of it. Beauty and the Beast (2017) grossed over a billion dollars regardless. Nostalgia helps and I was just happy to sing familiar songs in the theater.
Despite being auto-tuned, “Belle” has some nice choreography, but it doesn’t quite capture the grandness of Belle’s poor provincial town. “Belle” (Reprise) is about the same with a little less passion. “Gaston” is a great Disney villain song that’s a little too butchered with new lyrics. Gad gives it his all and Evans is no slouch, but they end up rambling a lot. The “Mob Song” is also a bit altered to fit LeFou’s character change. “Be Our Guest” is still a fine dining showstopper performed by Lumière with spectacular CGI visuals. “Something There” is almost exactly the same. “Beauty and the Beast” is as magical as its ever been, but Emma Thompson isn’t the best singer for the job. That’s why Audra McDonald takes over as part of the reprise. The signature song was also covered by Ariana Grande and John Legend for the music video.
As for the original songs, I’d be lying if I said they weren’t obvious Oscar bait. There’s a quick “Aria” for the opening ball scene performed by McDonald that I forgot about. “How Does a Moment Last Forever” is a sweet song that Kline performs well. The always exceptional Celine Dion returns to sing a cover during the closing credits. “Days in the Sun” is the new “Human Again” that I’d probably like better in another movie. The songs definitely start to pile up and I reached my breaking point after they gave the Beast his own power ballad after Belle leaves. “Evermore” is technically brilliant, but it just feels like a Broadway number. Save for a few nitpicks, Beauty and the Beast (2017) is one of the better live-action Disney remakes that holds a candle to an already perfect animated masterpiece.
Lumière makes Belle their guest
Live-Action Remake of: Beauty and the Beast (1991)